Sport

You're not signed in
Sign in
Sign up
STV Casino

Burley sacked: where did it all go wrong?

George Burley's time as Scotland manager is over after humiliation in Wales. Fraser Cardow and Grant Russell ask: where did it all go wrong?

By Fraser Cardow

17 November 2009 08:00 AM

121893

George Burley's time as Scotland manager is over after the SFA chose to sack the under-fire boss. After failing to secure World Cup qualification and the embarrassment in Wales, where did it all start to go wrong?

Defeat at the hands of Holland should have been the last straw for the manager who had to weather a storm of criticism as Scotland’s campaign faltered. But the Scotland manager insisted he wanted to stay and the Scottish Football Association decided to stick by the man who failed to build upon the promising work of Walter Smith and Alex McLeish.

But a humiliating 3-0 defeat away to Wales on Saturday raised questions again on the capability of Burley to lead his team to a successful 2012 European Championships qualifying campaign. Scotland also lost 2-0 away to Japan, but the number of call-offs and first caps provided a suitable excuse.

Yet well before Wales the seeds of Burley’s exit had been sewn far and wide. Baffling decisions to play Macedonia in scorching sunshine and against Norway before the Scottish season had started put the Scots off balance. They were more the SFA’s culpability than Burley’s but the manager’s tenure was to be tainted by further scandal and player controversy.

October 2008 saw Chris Iwelumo miss from two yards against the Norwegians. Hampden was agog, Kris Boyd was furious. Left on the bench in favour of the uncapped Iwelumo, the Rangers striker promptly retired from Burley’s Scotland. Iwelumo’s miss hung partly on his manager’s shoulders.

Arguably the most damaging chapter of Burley’s tenure arrived in April following his decision to sanction a drinking session after a 3-0 defeat in Holland. That led to the eruption of the now infamous “Boozegate” affair which ended the international careers of Barry Ferguson and Allan McGregor. Burley compounded the players’ actions with weak and confusing discipline, again in clumsy cahoots with Gordon Smith’s knee-jerk SFA.

The one time Hearts manager made it difficult for his players, announcing that only those playing first team football need apply; Lee McCulloch announced he would no longer play for Scotland after being left out of two squads. More recently David Weir was retired, by Burley, and then re-called a week later.

With an ever diminishing pool of players the manager was forced to call on some players who even the ever positive Tartan Army doubted. That came to a head with a 4-0 drubbing in Oslo as Norway. His captain was sent off, his formation was a shambles and his support evaporated.

Burley’s super-can-do attitude had become grating and unrealistic. His refusal to contemplate defeat set him further adrift from a Scottish support already largely resigned to missing yet another major championship.

“There will be a job vacancy soon," fortold a fans spokesman at the end of the 2010 campaign. “It’s not if and when. It’s who will be willing to take on the poisoned chalice.”

Last updated: 16 November 2009, 23:26

Share

The links provided allow you to bookmark this page into your favourite social media website. For users with JavaScript disabled copy and paste the URL from the address bar into your chosen social bookmarking site.

There are 2 comments

You need to be logged in to comment.

sign in

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

  1. Default avatar

    1. 17 Nov 2009 09:13Macrally said

    I aint a football fan but I feel sorry for Burley. These overpaid abnoxious men who think they are great at kicking a ball about - should realise they are being given a chance to play for their country. This should be an honour for them to be given the chance to do. Give yourselves a shake and go out there and be proud. Stop thinking about the money. If football is that great why do they need the money.

    Report as unsuitable

  2. Default avatar

    2. 17 Nov 2009 16:30Alex,Rosyth. said

    Why cant people be honest and face the real problem Scotland has to deal with. In an answer to Brian Taylor, (early evening, 17/11/09) an eminent professor stated: "Life, particularly in the west of Scotland, is dominated by very strong outside forces,the roots of which can be traced back to two football clubs" I agree with that and would add, particularly when certain political parties use this divide to retain control of the people. While the curse of sectarianism and bigotry exists,rife in the media and places of power, Scotland's progress, in all areas of culture, will be very slow indeed. Remember the problems Burley faced at the start of,(and during)) the Holland game. How to get rid of this sickness? Nae idea! But get rid of it we must if Scotland,in all areas of our culture is to rogress

    Report as unsuitable

Posts are not actively monitored by STV. The views expressed are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of STV.

SPL league table

Team Pld GD Pts
1 Rangers 23 40 54
2 Celtic 23 20 44
3 Hibernian 22 16 42
4 Dundee United 23 4 39
5 Motherwell 23 1 33
6 Hearts 23 -5 28
7 Aberdeen 22 -6 27
8 St Johnstone 20 -8 23
9 St Mirren 22 -11 20
10 Kilmarnock 23 -14 19
11 Falkirk 22 -18 17
12 Hamilton 22 -19 17

Related Articles

Video