Sport

You're not signed in
Sign in
Sign up

Rangers owe referee Craig Thomson a cup winning debt

Opinion: The cup final whistler may have simply being doing his job but his red cards for Rangers swung the game in their favour.

Ronnie Esplin

By Ronnie Esplin

22 March 2010 08:24 GMT

164989
Rangers owe referee Craig Thomson a cup winning debt

Masterstroke: Thomson's red card for Thomson's tackle on Thomson was exactly what Rangers needed. Pic: ©SNS Group

As regular readers of this page will know, I've never adhered to the popular conspiracy theory that referees go out of their way to help Rangers. But after Craig Thomson's performance in Sunday's Co-operative Insurance Cup final win over St Mirren, I'm simply not so sure anymore.

The Ibrox club were overwhelming favourites to beat the Saints, who were appearing in their first major final in 23 years and who had not registered a win in five previous meetings between the clubs this season. That the Buddies occupy second-bottom place in the SPL offered another pointer towards Walter Smith's side chalking off the first part of a potential treble.

However, in the first half the Govan men struggled. Gus MacPherson's men were bright, energetic and enthusiastic while Rangers plodded away as only Rangers can do. The Paisley side continued on the ascendancy in the early stages of the second half until, somewhat confusingly, Thomson sent off Thomson for a foul on Thomson.

Referee Craig Thomson must have sensed that Rangers and their fans needed something to get them going, a cause to rally round. So he brazenly reached for the red card when Light Blues' midfielder Kevin Thomson lunged at Buddies' midfielder Steven Thomson.

For the first time that afternoon the Rangers fans were heard. In their minds, if we take as evidence the vitriolic chants against the referee which followed, recent weeks and months of carping from Celtic and other clubs about officials giving the Ibrox side decisions had influenced the referee.

But they read the situation wrong. Thomson, the referee, not the Rangers player who swaggers although he has nothing to swagger about, was simply energising the Light Blues.

Down to 10 men, Rangers rallied. The tempo of the game increased, the extra yard was being run, the tackles and headers were being put in but as the minutes ticked away it seemed that the loss of one man wasn't enough.

So the referee sent off another one. Teenage defender Danny Wilson was second in to the showers for tugging at St Mirren substitute Craig Dargo as he raced towards Neil Alexander in the Rangers goal.

The Scottish Football League would have been as well putting the red, white and blue ribbons on the cup there and then and calling David Weir up the Hampden steps to collect it. It would have saved us all 20 minutes or so.

Rangers fans were incensed and they railed vociferously against the referee, if not the world. They also roared their team on and the Ibrox players took inspiration from the perceived sense of injustice.

The referee's calculated ploy paid off minutes from time when Kenny Miller rose to head Steven Naismith's cross past Paul Gallacher and a game that had earlier threatened to escape Smith's side ended in glory.

Of course, I jest about Craig Thomson. He made those two big decisions for no other reason than they were right. That Rangers responded positively to them was neither here nor there, as far as he was concerned.

You can excuse young Wilson for his mistake. Despite the hype that surrounds him he is a long way from the finished article and he perhaps panicked when caught for pace by Dargo but Smith accepted the decision.

The Rangers boss was less sure about Thomson's dismissal, calling it "soft". But for most people, it was simply another example of Thomson trying to ingratiate himself with the Rangers support by acting the part of an enforcer. It is way past time someone at Ibrox took him aside to tell him that football isn't like that any more. Yellow and red cards do not maketh a midfielder.

He could do well to look at team mate Miller who for all his faults, and God knows I've bored many people highlighting them, is a player of true courage. When people lecture about having to have the right mentality to play for the Old Firm, they should put a picture of the former Celtic striker on their Powerpoint presentation.

Playing through suspicion and indifference at Parkhead, where he arrived as an ex-Ranger, then battling past naked hatred at Ibrox when he returned for a second spell, he has never once shirked his responsibilities.

His goal on Sunday had a touch of class about it and afterwards he admitted feeling "goosebumps" on hearing the Rangers fans chant his name for the first time since he arrived back at Ibrox in the summer of 2008. He deserved that and more.

In praising Miller as an individual, the team spirit and attitude at Rangers has to be again acknowledged.  There is something about winning a cup final with nine men, a second-choice keeper, a centre-back who is almost 40 and a striker playing in defence that makes me question Scottish football.

However, in the wake of a remarkable cup triumph, that would be churlish. Smith's squad possess a determination and a tenaciousness that is associated more closely with the Rangers teams of Jock Wallace.

The Ibrox men again showed that regardless of what criticisms are levelled against them with regards their style of football, they are never found wanting when it comes to the fight.

Ads by Google

Share

There are 4 comments

You need to be logged in to comment.

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

  1. Default avatar

    1. 22 Mar 2010 09:34Nelster said

    Ronnie, as most regular readers of any comment by you will know, it's nauseating and typically niggly without ever saying something of note.

    2 things caused the red card. Kevin Thomson's frustration and Craig Thomson's downright incompetence, missing 2 shocking challenges on both Kevin Thomson and Kenny Miller 30 seconds earlier.

    BBC co-commentator Craig Paterson wasn't slow to voice this opinion, no-one else on the TV coverage saw fit to see the bigger picture. Having witnessed some truly astonishing decisions over 60 minutes, Kevin Thomson lost his discipline when rugby tackled in front of the referee.

    Yeah he needs to cut it out, but it could've been any one of the Rangers squad. Indeed you appear to have missed Kenny Miller's fisticuffs in the aftermath.... no shock there.

    To decry someone as having "a swagger when he nothing to swagger about" is symptomatic of the cretins in the Scottish media.

    A boss of the Old Firm game, 6 out of 6.

    A Scottish internationalist.

    A player who had all but consigned Barry Ferguson as a backup player

    Report as unsuitable

  2. Default avatar

    2. 22 Mar 2010 09:36Nelster said

    By the way, congratulations on getting STV to hide your piece "Cash Rich Celtic should dominate this unhealthy SPL"

    We haven't forgotten.

    Report as unsuitable

  3. Default avatar

    3. 22 Mar 2010 14:13Saintstevie said

    It's hardly hidden, it's even got his coupon on it:

    http://sport.stv.tv/...ch-celtic/

    Or perhaps you and your pals in the Elephant Loyal haven't worked out what Google is for yet.

    Report as unsuitable

  4. Default avatar

    4. 23 Mar 2010 07:43Jakester said

    What trash. The paranoid brigade strikes again. Celtic don't win the league because referees didn't send off Rangers players, St. Mirren don't win the cup because referees did send off Rangers players.

    What a well balanced view. A chip on both shoulders.

    Get someone who can write a decemt article pleasite a decent article please !!!

    Report as unsuitable

You need to be logged in to comment.

sign in

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

Posts are not actively monitored by STV. The views expressed are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of STV.

Watch now

Video